Friday, 24 July 2020

A Coloured Route That Leads From Leeds (2)?


This blog explains how one organisation is aiming to:-

Promote the use of public transport
Improve publicity
Make bus travel easier

Sorry, but such ideas are unknown to the SYPTE - hence the health warning.

The initiative under review comes from a similar organisation a few miles north via the M1 ...
... under the brand:-
So here is the introduction to the document.

We would like to share with you our plans to improve the information you use to plan journeys and use the bus system around Leeds. We want to make it easier to plan and take bus journeys by creating a user-friendly and accessible set of maps and new colour coded bus stop flags, shelters and other on-street infrastructure that link to bus lines across the city. We have created 13 bus lines that group together existing services to help you easily navigate the core bus network and get you from A to B.

These improvements are planned on the core bus network for stops with services that run at least every 15 minutes or serve key destinations.

We've created a trial bus stop in the city centre to show you how our proposals might work.

CURRENT BUS SHELTER
PROPOSED ENHANCEMENTS
No great excitement so far. P.S. The shelter above is NOT at Wade Lane, unless there has been some recent building of repro old properties!
THE REAL WADE LANE STOP
But there is more.
The stop is getting a coloured band. But there is even more.
There is a redesigned bus stop flag - also incorporating a red flash, the operator name (that's First Bus in a heavy disguise) and the appropriate route numbers on a strange shaped white outline.

This has probably been "designed" and, also probably, been "designed" by someone who isn't used to peering through rain bespotted spectacles at very small numbers.
Back to the introduction.

What are we doing?

We are creating a package of wayfinding maps and enhancements to bus flags and bus shelters that reflect the colours and names of the bus lines across the city. These improvements are planned for stops on the core bus network with services that run at least every 15 minutes or serve key destinations.

This map is an easy to use map of the core bus network across the city. It includes named and coloured route lines to help you find which bus you need to take to get from A to B. The map will be displayed at key locations across Leeds and in most bus shelters on the network.

Sounds a jackpot idea! Let' s look at the map.

And there is the First Bus 51 and 52 to  Morley   ...
 ... complete with labels ("designed") with the bottom right hand corner rounded off. The map also has its corner rounded off!
The First Bus route map shows the 51 and 52 as MAGENTA ...
... and it also shows an extra one way squiggle via Queen Street which isn't on the new PTE version. Back in Overground days the 51/52 were an near anonymous grey and not given a "line" name.
Tingley Mill = Morley in the distanced world of Leeds PTE cartography.

So will First have to change its map? And if so what about the other end of the cross city 51 and 52?
In the PTE's "cunning plan" Moor Allerton is part of the Meanwood "corridor" ...
... and coloured CYAN.

Aha! An answer. When a 51 gets into the city centre from Morley a bevy of First Bus staff whip out their step ladders and paste a CYAN wedge over the RED before the bus zooms northwards via Meanwood.
Actually, fbb doesn't think that the 51 and 52 are equipped with buses adorned with coloured wedges, but he does know that red-wedged green buses ...
... do not run to Morley or via Meanwood - they run to Holt Park; which is MID BLUE ...
... on the PTE "corridor" map and CYAN and BROWN ...
... on the First Bus version.

We are, probably, in a position to summarise.

Three sets of colours are either in use or proposed for Leeds City bus services. They are, in order of old age ...

First Bus network map and route maps
First Bus coloured wedges on some vehicles
The PTE proposal for colour-coded bus corridors

... and they all use a different palette of colours.

Confused.com?

And then there is the City Centre. Like most tourist-conscious communities, Leeds had designated a series of "quarters" in a valiant attempt to define various chunks of the city centre.
Leeds doesn't have one obvious "centre" - not unusual for large conurbations - but it does make defining bus stops somewhat challenging.

So the PTE has had another jackpot idea. Split the centre into a series of "zones" and define bus stops with reference to those named blocks of roads.

Generally speaking, the names bear no resemblance to the "quarters"above ...
... but they are used in the stop names. (click on the graphic below to enlarge it)
Note also that more routes have joined the corridors, namely out-of-town services like Arriva's 254 and 255 to Cleckheaton and beyond. These have been branded, at one time, with a yellow stripe ...
... more recently with a purple splodge.
They run at a combined 15 minute frequency to Cleckheaton ...
... but have unexplained blue dashes mixed in with their yellow (gold?).

On balance, fbb would prefer to see the colours at the city centre stop blobs - ot would that be too much and too dotty?

Of course, the map has a well "designed" rounded corner ...
... as does the stops list.
And, talking of the stops list, why is Dewsbury Road not in alphabetical order? Maybe somebody forgot it!
Poor Dewsbury Road!

Before committing to this plan, fbb suggests that the PTE people might have a chat to the First Bus people about colours and cross-city services.

Meanwhile, First Bus people need to talk to First Bus people about colours in their maps versus coloured wedges on their shiny new green buses.

One departments of First talking to another department of First - now there IS a novelty!

Overall, however, with consistency and if FULLY implemented, the PTE's plan has much to commend it.

Teacher says "A good idea and well presented but more work needed on the detail." And PLEASE, larger print on the bus stop flags so that we can see them!

 Next mixed-bag blog : Saturday 25th July 

9 comments:

  1. I think the most successful coloured route system is to be found in Nottingham where it is common to the vehicles, the routes/"lines", and the roadside publicity. But there are no significant cross-city routes: do the good folk of Leeds need so many?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They probably don't need so many cross town links, but it's probably the most economical way of providing the service as they won't have excess layover in the City centre

      Delete
    2. The 2, 3, 3A, 12, 13 & 13A are all linked together as one service which takes 4 hours to do complete the circuit. This crosses the city centre 4 times, twice Northbound and twice Southbound, pre COVID it ran every 10 minutes & had a PVR of about 48 buses:
      https://www.firstgroup.com/uploads/maps/2.3.3A.12.13.13A%20Leeds%20Map_0.pdf P.S. Nottingham did have cross city routes before the services were rebranded into corridors.

      Delete
  2. Do the blue dashes copy the vertical blue line to the left of the same route numbers, perhaps implying Arriva as the operator?
    Similarly, the First routes have a green line by the route number, implying that they are run by Leeds City?

    ReplyDelete
  3. It all sounds very good but at the moment, as I understand it, with the closure of the Headrow, a main east-west artery, for improvements some buses from the west of Leeds no longer go to the bus station but terminate on city centre streets. Sounds more like "Disconnecting Leeds".
    I wonder if full implementation of this plan is for when the Headrow re-opens.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The city centre map has 13 stops labelled A, which is a bit confusing as they are all in the same colour. I think that that each area needs a separate colour and a two letter code e.g CS for City Square with the stops CS1, CS2 etc. I have said as much in the survey I have just completed: https://mail-wymetro.com/3LTT-15QBF-3SQVIZ-Q2MER-1/c.aspx

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello everyone, Are you into trading or just wish to give it a try, please becareful on the platform you choose to invest on and the manager you choose to manage your account because that’s where failure starts from be wise. After reading so much comment i had to give trading tips a try, I have to come to the conclusion that binary options pays massively but the masses has refused to show us the right way to earn That’s why I have to give trading tips the accolades because they have been so helpful to traders . For a free masterclass strategy kindly contact (paytondyian699@gmail.com) for a free masterclass strategy. He'll give you a free tutors on how you can earn and recover your losses in trading for free..

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for sharing this valuable information.

    Apparrant is the leading UX UI Design agency having experienced designers and developers working throughout the year on important and life changing products. We have been awarded as top UI UX Design agency in India by multiple agencies. If you are looking for best UX Design Agency in Noida, UI UX Design Agency in Faridabad, and UX UI Design Company in Delhi then Apparrant is best for you.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow its a great blog.
    Best Jewellery Wholesaler in Jaipur is Ratnavali. It is a best place to buy silver jewellery Jaipur, Jaipuri gold jewellery, gemstone figures in Jaipur, Rajasthan. We have skilled craftsmanship who made best designer collection of jewellery for you.

    ReplyDelete